If you have ever heard someone describe a Scottish accent, it’s possible you’ve heard that Scottish people “roll their Rs”. You may also have heard people say that this is the reason they can’t do a Scottish accent.
Do Scottish people really all “roll their Rs”? Are Scottish “r” sounds difficult to make? What is a “rolled r”? Read to find out more and hear some real examples of Scottish R sounds.
Do Scottish People Really Roll their Rs?
The quick answer to this is yes, but only some people – and you may find it is more common with older speakers.
A rolled R is a sound you might know from languages such as Spanish or Italian. In linguistics, it is called a “trill”. Skip to 2:50 in this video for an example of rolled Rs or trills in the Spanish words “pero” and “perro”:
Next, listen to the R sound when Scottish actor James McAvoy says “I’m actually very proud to be from Scotland” (skip to 1:40):
Did you hear the difference? In the Scottish example, the rolled R was very short. In fact, it maybe didn’t sound like a rolled R at all! This is the type of “rolled R” you will find in Scottish accents. Instead of lots of vibrations – or “rolls” of the tongue – in a row, there is just one short vibration.
So: some Scottish people do roll their R sounds, but the sound is shorter than you might think. What else is there to learn about Scottish accents and R sounds?
Rhoticity is a fancy word to describe whether or not an accent pronounces R sounds wherever it is possible to do so – i.e. pretty much wherever you see an R in the spelling of a word.
If you have ever studied different English accents, you may have been taught the following:
- In American English, you should pronounce the R sound at the end of words like “car”, “better” or “card”
- In British English, you should not pronounce this R sound. Instead, make an “ah” sound, e.g. “caah” for “car”
Of course, if you are following Speaking Scottish, you probably know that there is more than just one accent in the UK – and definitely more than one in Scotland too!
So what does a rhotic accent sound like? Let’s have at the following three words:
How do you say them?
If you have learnt British English from a traditional textbook, you may pronounce these words like this speaker (listen to 1:11-1:49). If instead you have learnt US English, your pronunciation may be closer to these videos: paw, pour and poor.
Now have a listen to the following recordings from Scottish speakers:
Did you notice that in the Scottish recordings, all of the words sound different? Have another listen – you should hear an R at the end of both “pour” and “poor”. You might also have noticed that the vowel sounds are all different. We will look at this another day!
Remember: although the above audio clips show a big difference between many Scottish, English and American accents, R sounds are pronounced differently – or not at all – in different areas and by different people throughout the UK as well as in US and elsewhere. There is never one rule for absolutely everyone!
More Scottish R Sounds
We now know that while some Scottish people do roll their “r”s, this isn’t true of everyone. So what other R sounds are common in Scotland? The quick answer is:
- Tap R sounds – sounds where your tongue taps against the roof of your mouth
- Approximants R sounds – sounds where your tongue almost touches the roof of your mouth
Read on to hear some examples.
- Tap R Sounds
Many younger speakers in Scotland will use tap “r”s.
The most common R sound in Scotland today is called an alveolar tap, written as [ɾ] in the International Phonetic Alphabet (IPA). For many people, this R sound is one of the first things they will notice about Scottish speech. Usually it is used in combination with approximant R sounds – Rs where your tongue almost touches the roof of your mouth.
The reason this type of R is called an alveolar tap is because to make the sound, your tongue must quickly tap the alveolar ridge – the hard area on the roof of your mouth just behind your teeth.
In this clip, listen to Glaswegian actor Richard Madden’s R sounds when he says “thank you very much” (1:08) and “crew and cast” (1:18):
Now listen to Edinburgh author Irvine Welsh’s R sounds when he says “they were there to service the industry” (2:40) and “my brain and my fingers aren’t wired correctly” (4:00):
Finally, listen out for musician Amy Macdonald, from Bishopbriggs near Glasgow, and her R sounds when she says “I was on stage in Switzerland on Saturday” (0:29):
2. Approximant R Sounds
Another kind of R you are likely to hear in Scotland is something called approximants. This is something you may already know from Irish or American English, and involves R sounds where the tongue never touches the roof of the mouth.
In Scotland, many people use only this type of R pronunciation no matter where the R sound comes in the word (e.g. before and after vowels).
For example, listen to actress Kelly Macdonald, who grew up in Newton Mearns near Glasgow, and her R sounds when she says “from London, we were in London for years and years” (00:39):
Also listen out for fellow actress Shirley Henderson, who grew up in Kincardine-on-Forth in Fife, when she says “a master improv” (1:23):
Other Scottish R Sounds
As well as those we’ve just talked about, there are some other R sounds you might hear in Scotland. These include:
- Uvular Trill [ʀ] or Uvular Fricative [ʁ] – R sounds made in the back of the throat (similar to in French or German)
- R-Vocalisation – where “r” is pronounced like a vowel (a newer type of R sound mostly common with young people in urban parts of the Central Belt)
If you are keen to find out more about these varieties, check out the “Find Out More” section below for further reading.
How Difficult are Scottish R Sounds?
If you’ve read this far, you may be interested in learning to make Scottish R sounds yourself. If you’re lucky, you may have something similar to a Scottish R sound in your own language. If not, and if it still feels very difficult, don’t give up – like all things, it takes practice!
Here are some ideas you could try:
- Listen to people around you. How do they pronounce R? Can you try copying them?
- Listen to Scottish accents on podcasts, in music or in films.
- Ask a Scottish friend – see if they’ll help you practise some words or phrases.
Even if you don’t want to practise your own Scottish accent, understanding Scottish accents will help you to communicate with those around you in Scotland.
We hope that this article has helped you learn a bit more about R sounds, and that you feel ready to go out and practise “speaking Scottish“!
Find Out More
- Corbett, J., McClure, J., & Stuart-Smith, J. (2003). The Edinburgh Companion to Scots (pp. 126-135). Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
- Lingthusiasm Episode 55: R and R-Like Sounds
- Millar, R. (2018). Modern Scots (pp. 90-94). Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
- Scots Syntax Atlas
- Scottish Corpus of Texts & Speech (SCOTS)
This article was a collaboration between the Core Speaking Scottish Team and Sara Iličić.
Sara Iličić is a student in Linguistics at the University of Edinburgh. Her main areas of interest are phonology and dialectology, and she is currently researching glottaling in Edinburgh dialects.